The world of online advertising is going through a period of deep changes since some of the most popular browsers (such as Firefox and Mozilla) have begun to limit first, and then delete third-party cookies. If we cannot call it a real revolution until Google too, which holds control of almost 70% of the ad market, does not take the same steps by the end of 2023, professionals from this field are already looking for new alternatives to overcome the losses that this paradigm shift will entail.

Cookies, so important in the modern virtual landscape, are nothing more than tiny text strings that allow the reading of a series of data from those who installed them (generally, site name and an ID, but it can also include elements of the site configuration, such as the choice of language). They can be temporary (session cookies) or permanent. Cookies are used to collect user data and can be either an aggregate of anonymous information, such as page clicks, pages viewed, or a PII (Personal Identifiable Information) based on personal data, such as the ID of the device, names, addresses, passwords and credit card numbers.

Cookie Rawfish

Their task is to remain in the background and communicate bits of information once the user connects to a given server, with the aim of providing a more personalized experience to the user, or collecting information to be used for purposes of marketing. They are generally divided into three macro-categories:

Technical cookies: they are those cookies present on a site, to provide a service requested by the user. The stored information is used to improve the user experience on a given site, generally using that information to implement the actions most often requested by the user (such as memorizing passwords).

Analytical cookies: also called statistical cookies due to their analysis and monitoring function, they try to improve the user experience by analyzing their habits within the site of reference, to create patterns that facilitate navigation.

Profiling cookies: these are the cookies that will be most affected by the paradigm shift. They are in fact those cookies that track the user’s navigation for marketing reasons, in order to propose targeted advertising messages in line with the information obtained.

“Cookieless world” is however a misleading definition. In fact, cookies will not disappear from the internet world as the name would suggest. Instead, there will be an almost total resizing of third-party cookies, that is, those cookies, almost always used for profiling, entered into the system from different domains than the one where the user is currently browsing. Although they are among the most used, in fact, these cookies also represent a risk to the user’s privacy, who is often bombarded with intrusive messages, which are not always in line with his tastes and likes. For this reason, in recent years there has already been a proliferation of ad hoc laws to regulate what is in fact a chaotic sector, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) of the European Union and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), introduced in the United States.

Since then, limitations on track using this technology have increased, even extending beyond the limits of the web browser and cookies. The philosophy behind it has changed, just as the default tracking settings have moved from opt-out consent (e.g. assuming there is a consent unless the user actively decides to unsubscribe or deny their data) to opt-in consent (that is, it does not presuppose consent unless it is explicitly given by the user, as in the case of zero-party cookies). The main challenge for marketers in the cookieless world will therefore be trying to balance cookies so that a meeting point is found between the user’s needs and their privacy concerns.

The banning of third party cookies will allow users to be able to see more clearly which partners will use their data, while for companies the change of paradigm will mean seeking new solutions to overcome the loss of information and develop strategies for the detection of other data, relying more persistently on other tactics.

Rawfish cookie

Zero-party and First-party cookies will be the new focus

The first consequence of marketing in this new environment will be to focus on cookies containing information that users spontaneously share with domains. Among these, the most sought after will be the email address and dates of birth, easily obtainable from questionnaires that the user can fill out. These will be zero-party cookies or cookies that derive from information that users actively provide to the site, generally by filling in a questionnaire or through other forms of sharing within an opt-in view. This is the principle of do ut des: I give you my data in exchange for valuable content of informative and/or commercial nature. The main advantage of these data is that they are generally selected from those that do not change significantly or randomly over time, therefore they are the most reliable, compared to third-party cookies that generally dredge any information, thus not limited to invalidating the privacy, but also to collect data that, being changing over time, do not represent customers on an ongoing basis, thus providing profiles that distort over time until they are no longer in line with the user, consequently bombarding them with invasive and uninteresting marketing. The use of this information will also help build trust on the part of the user, who will know what data they have intentionally shared and who will use them, probably feeling less threatened in terms of privacy.

A similar argument also applies to first-party cookies, ie those that collect information directly on the domain which the user is currently browsing, generally with the aim of making the very same browsing more fluid. The data comes from customer purchases, customer service, as well as marketing programs. Examples of proprietary data include demographics, purchase history, website activity, email engagement, and sales interactions. The most sought-after information, in this case, is again the email address, as it is generally used to access various services and is a relatively immutable element to be used (names and dates can be changed, while the email address, which must be then often confirmed via a message to the email itself, cannot be changed at will).

Cookie Rawfish

Other methods of targeting and measurement

Among the most popular alternatives to zero and first-party cookies, we find other solutions such as:

MAID (mobile advertising ID): an identifier provided by the operating system of a mobile device in order to track the user. There are still doubts regarding this technology, which is currently unregulated and could also be interpreted as invasive of user privacy. To overcome this problem, both Apple and Google are examining solutions to allow access to user data only through forms of opt-in.

Universal ID: user identification systems, initially born as a method to find cross-platform tracking mechanisms that do not lay their foundations in the context of the use of cookies. They can be based on deterministic data (such as email in the example above), or probabilistic (IP address, timestamp, etc.).

Topics: this method was introduced by Google after giving up the FLoC (Federated Learning of Cohorts). A solution to provide data to companies on profiles that are based only on data from the last week of navigation. The system would keep this data for a limited period, and only three topics of interest will be shared with partner companies at a time.

Contextual Advertising: this is a type of targeting based on the information obtained from navigation, based on the web content of the landing page. The conveyed message will be matched and relevant to the metadata and the content of the web page. Not taking into account the user’s history, but only the data collected on the spot, it is considered one of the least invasive and most functional techniques.

AI-Based Solutions: technologies that combine different specific elements (identity solutions, format, data, positioning, audience), and that through predictive algorithms make use of this information to trace a virtual identity of the user, in order to convey the advertising in the most efficient way possible.